Motor are they really the same
I wonder if brushless motors made at the same Chinese factories are really the same ! For example ,is a Eflight 10 the same inside as the cheaper motor made by the same factory?
While the specs are similar the price difference is almost 50 to 30 percent less.
The quality of components is a big difference. Magnets, the stator core, and bearings vary vastly in quality. Some of those really cheap bell type motors use really crappy components and you are likely only getting about 40-50% of the input power to the prop. High quality brushless can go well into the 80% efficiency realm. Brushed can be into the 90% range! So you may be flushing almost half of your power down the drain.
The question is - does it matter? On some planes I just don't care and I want the cheap. Like our full contact combat models. Cheap is all you want as you will crash all the time.
When comparing an E-flite motor you must consider it is sold by a company that does have a higher quality standard, R&D, advertising and a MUCH better service and return policy. All of those items raise costs.
I am perfectly happy with cheap motors on some planes but use much higher quality motors on planes I care about. It is just nice to have a choice.
Thank you .
I will pay a little bit more and get the Eflite 10 for my Chrysalis. FishHawk
There are factories that make the same (or similar) motors for multiple vendors. The difference is that they will use cheaper materials for one vendor/price point and the best for another vendor/price point. It all depends on what the vendor asks for. Same with ARF planes, you may find a model identical to one from a "big name" vendor but at half or less the price at Company X - but if you tear the two down side-by-side you'll find one has better wood, better glue joints and better covering even though they were made in the same factory by the same people. Company X wanted a cheaper copy and that's exactly what they got.
Sounds like marketing has a lot of influence on the final product. FishHawk
|All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:22 PM.|
Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 2005 WattfFlyer.com
RCU Eflight HQ