WattFlyer RC Electric Flight Forums - Discuss radio control eflight

WattFlyer RC Electric Flight Forums - Discuss radio control eflight (https://www.wattflyer.com/forums/index.php)
-   Batteries & Chargers (https://www.wattflyer.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Load checker without using motor / ESC etc. (https://www.wattflyer.com/forums/showthread.php?t=82279)

solentlife 03-15-2022 11:35 AM

Load checker without using motor / ESC etc.
I am sure that I am not only LiPo user that has a lot of LiPos' and amongst the many - are odd ones that at times do not perform. I try to mark them as ?? to avoid using again ... but one or two can get used again and occasionally seem to be OK.

I have a bench set-up .... motor mounted to a flat plate I can clamp in a vice ... ESC and Servo Tester .... I can connect wattmeter and run up to observe / listenm and read results. But its a pain having to charge up the LiPo - then connect - run and then storage discharge.

I've tried using the Internal Resistance values to check - I have a dedicated IR meter as well as on the chargers ... but that has not proven to be solution.

So ? Question is - what is there out there that can be used to reliably determine a LiPo's condition without too mucxh work involved ... lets say charge up to average 4.0v per cell .. plug into XXXX ... load is imposed and you get direct result ?? I know that sounds like a Wattmeter exercise - but I'm looking for something that does not need ESC / Wattmeter / Servo Tester etc.

Any ideas Guys and Gals ??

Wildflyer 03-16-2022 06:51 AM

I saw someplace that if a fully charged Lipo is loaded to a point that the voltage output drops anything over 0.3 volts per cell then that is the current limit for that particular battery. Basically the C rating of that battery at that time.
The guy explained that if a 4 cell battery dropped over 1.2 volts in total then that would be the limit of current for it.

I don't know if this is all true, it seems a bit harsh to me. If it is true, then many of my batteries are over the hill.

I haven't heard of anything new other than the SkyRC BD250 Battery Discharger & Analyzer and similar devices

solentlife 03-16-2022 09:16 AM

0.3V per cell .... blimey - that's not much ..... IMHO - thats being super kind to the battery.

Wildflyer 03-16-2022 07:47 PM

I fully agree Nigel,
I don't know how much of an "Expert" the author is on batteries, but he made it into the book.

solentlife 03-16-2022 08:15 PM

My reason for looking is that I am currently going through my huge collection of LiPo's ...

First charge up to max 4.2V per cell.
Read of Charger the Internal Resistance of each cell. I know temp makes a difference - but I'm looking for big differences not small.
I have test motor with 11x5.5 prop on board clamped in a vice. Sevo Tester control and ESC /BEC

I have found before that IR results are not as reliable as some claim ...

Example : Cells are in mOhms ... Motor test is bad * ... fair ** Good ***

LiPo # ...... Cell 1 ........ Cell 2 ......... Cell 3 ............. Motor test
#4 ..............066 ........... 021 ........... 023 ................***
#5 ............. 066 .......... 008 .......... 011 ................ **

They are same size / capacity / brand .... I would expect #5 to perfo0rm as good as or better than #4 ... but it did not. It was plainly less capable.

CHELLIE 04-05-2022 11:54 AM

maybe this Lipo tester might help,

pmullen503 04-07-2022 10:11 PM

On the subject of voltage drops under load.

Before I had telemetry, I set a timer so I'd land at around storage voltage. That way I could pack up batteries and go home without having to mess with them. Now, I set my telemetry alarms for 3.3V/cell. If they go off under power, it's time to land. I want to have at least 3.7V/cell resting (again, pretty much storage voltage).

The point is if my alarms are going off but I still have more than say 3.8V/cell I know that battery is getting weak and it gets "de-rated" for use in less demanding planes. So while I may get one or two years in an EDF, but the same battery can still be fine for use in prop planes for several more years.

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:45 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2022 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.

Page generated in 0.06917 seconds with 10 queries